Tagged: Carl Graham

Posted: November 1, 2012 at 12:45 pm

Bizarre Testimony from Gallik’s Accuser; bad times for GOP in court

If you think the black helicopter crowd lives only in rural Montana, think again.

Recall that when Dave Gallik was forced out as Commissioner of Political Practices last year, there was a feeling among readers at the time that something didn’t smell quite right.  His four employees had rummaged through desk and photocopied his notes, kept tabs on his comings and goings, and sent it all to reporters.  They even called the police one time without any legitimate explanation.  There was a feeling among many observers (and many commenters here) that something smelled fishy, especially when the now-infamous photo appeared on the front of the IR, the four women posing for the photographer, seeming to bask in the glow of their 15 minutes of sunlight.

Gallik has always maintained that he was framed by four people who were out to get him because he was a tough boss who forced them to change their ways, and they were resistant.

Well, yesterday Gallik got his day in court.   And one of his chief accusers, Julie Steab, one of the employees who made some of the strongest accusations against Gallik in the press, was called to the stand.

To the shock of observers in court and the embarrassment of the attorney bringing the case against Gallik, Ms. Steab testified that she was the target of a surveillance operation, that “an unknown person or persons” were “following her” around, day and night, in the aftermath of Gallik’s resignation.  She also testified that the other three women in the office were similarly tailed. But Mary Baker, one of the other employees, took the stand after Steab and stated that she had never been followed nor did she know of any case where any of the four employees were followed.

I’d say Steab’s bizarre testimony is grounds for the press and public to reconsider Gallik’s tenure and the events surrounding his departure.  In my opinion, he was brought down by at least one woman whose credibility has been shattered, whose testimony yesterday clearly suggests to me some type of paranoia or tendency toward fantasy.

The attorney bringing the case was none other than the Tea Partier Art Wittich, suing Gallik on behalf of the Montana Policy Institute, the right-wing think tank.  Wittich, like most GOP attorneys in Montana, spends his days suing the Governor, Steve Bullock, Commissioners past and present, and Democrats generally. Clearly his star witness, Steab, did not deliver, destroyed her own credibility, and caused Wittich some embarrassment.  Poor guy.  It’s kind of like calling a witness to the stand, who upon cross examination confesses to having been abducted by aliens, or having seen Elvis still alive in Hawaii.

Which leads me to a humorous final point, a general pattern of events the last few weeks:

It’s been a dry spell for GOP attorneys.  A few weeks back, Rick Hill hired Bozeman Tea Party hot-head Monforton to give him legal advice. It it was Monforton’s idea to take the $500,000 donation, it was perhaps the worst legal advice in Montana political history, probably destroying Hill’s campaign.  Then another of Hill’s lawyers, Cory Swanson, a young corporate lobbyist and lawyer who makes a living suing the Schweitzer administration, got his head handed to him in district court by three top-rank democratic lawyers, the judge barring Hill from spending the illegal $500k.  Jim Brown, another conservative attorney who represents right-wing American Tradition Partnership, was caught on camera with a mouthful of marbles when presented clear evidence that his client broke the law by coordinating with GOP candidates; he had no response to the reporter, and turned red in the face.   Brown had to then contend with a crowd of protesters outside his office the day after the PBS story aired (though he was a good sport about it, fielding questions from members of the hostile crowd).  Now Wittich puts his star witness on the stand to make his case, and she says that big brother is watching her day and night. Bwahahahaaa!

Posted: May 9, 2012 at 5:09 pm

Pro-Rehberg Blogger Fled Idaho Under Cloud

Dustin Hurst is a right-wing blogger that recently arrived in Helena from Idaho, and has written stories defending Congressman Dennis Rehberg and the Montana GOP, and attacking Democrats.  He calls himself a “reporter.”  His “articles” are trash with no connection to facts or truth.  Last week, for example, he wrote a story saying that Schweitzer is “happy with high unemployment.”  He also claimed that Rob Stutz had called for a pre-emptive strike against Iran, as this video explains.  Intelligent Discontent did a write up of the factual problems with some of the other blog posts Hurst was responsible for.

Hurst works for the Montana Watchdog, a somewhat absurd website that is a subsidiary of the right-wing Montana Policy Institute.  It is believed that the site is funded by Koch Brothers’s-type donors from out of state, but it’s never really been clear who the funders are as the supposed purveyors of sunshine and light don’t disclose their own backers.

What you should know about Hurst is that while working for a blog called TheIdahoReporter.com, he got busted for lying about his identity while trying to chase down a story about a Democratic state lawmaker.   The Idaho Statesman reported the incident.

In addition to blogging, Hurst is a busy but uninteresting Twitterer, Hurst has also shared his opinions on everything from Bill Maher, Obama, paying taxes and Taco Bell.  On one night alone, Hurst used up five tweets on the fact he was watching the latest Tom Cruise movie.

The internet also contains a frightful collection of Dustin Hurst photos, including:

Dustin Hurst rapping

Dustin Hurst ridiculing a disabled person

Dustin Hurst supporting the war and George W. Bush

and Dustin Hurst drinking an unknown beverage lying in the street

 

Posted: March 21, 2011 at 7:20 am

GOP Whining Violates Code of the West

The Havre Daily news has written a must-read, in-depth story about the national (and negative) media attention that the Repubs in the Montana legislature have brought upon themselves and our state, with their various nutty bills on secession, nullification, allowing guns in school, hunting with silencers, birth certificate requirements for candidates, returning the state to the gold standard, encouraging global warming, and so on and so forth.

(On Thursday the GOP voted to keep “sodomy” an imprisonable offense, by the way).

But apparently a bunch of GOP legislators believe that this national embarrassment was caused not by themselves, but by “the media”. They feel they did nothing wrong, but have been unfairly represented in the reporting.  Wendy Warburton, for example says the media is “sensationalizing” the story while “ignoring important bills.” Warburton even trashed her own hometown newspaper by saying that it was “being political” for even doing a story on how she, herself, has helped bring national ridicule.  In response, Markos Moulitsas, founder of Daily Kos says:

“Now, Republicans can whine that the coverage is unfair because not everything they do is crazy, but that would be like a death row inmate whining that his punishment is unfair because he didn’t spend all his time killing someone.”

I believe “The Code of the West” says something about taking responsibility for your actions rather than blaming everyone else for a mess you create. But to show how absurd the GOP’s reasoning is, the Havre Daily story even has Bob Wagner complaining about how the media is to blame.

That’s especially hilarious because Wagner booked himself an interview on CNN to promote his new policy he is advocating, that not only must a candidate for office in Montana produce a birth certificate, he or she must also prove that both parents were born in America. His leader, senate president Jim Peterson, also booked himself a national spot, on Fox News, to promote his bill to “adopt the The Code of the West as the official ‘Code of Montana.’”)

Rowlie Hutton, another nutjob, says in the article that “these bills are all good for our future” and says it “must have been a slow news day” for them to get national coverage.

Also complaining in the article is Carl Graham (occasional contributor here), head of the conservative Montana Policy Institute. Graham offers up this gem, blaming Schweitzer for the negative attention that the legislature is getting. He says it’s all the fault of the liberal elites back east, portraying Montanans as “ignorant rubes” and that:

“Our governor, by the way, only reinforces that stereotype when he does his ‘aw shucks, that dog won’t hunt’ and ‘there’s critters need’n brand’n’ routine for Bill Maher and his other friends in the national media who look at us as their cultural inferiors….(These stories) are merely cases of the cultural and media elite playing to their mostly urban and liberal fan base by pulling out an old stereotype of rural states like Montana.”

So to be clear, it is not the GOP who are to blame; it is the way Schweitzer speaks that is causing the problem.

Graham, it could be argued, is not as far to the right as some of the wingnuts who have created the mess for the GOP. But he’s feeling the sting of what has transpired. He, and others in the “mainstream” GOP (if there is such a thing), have been dragooned into a swamp of humiliation by the Tea Party takeover of 2010.

And you know what? Too bad, so sad. The Code of the West also says “you ride with outlaws, you hang with them.”

If the Repubs wanna be divorced from the lunatic ravings of their fringe, they need to act on it, just like they said Obama should have “denounced” Jeremiah Wright and all that stuff. Otherwise they are riding with the outlaws, and they are a part of the shenanigans and will (and should) be held to answer for them.

Posted: August 2, 2010 at 7:27 pm

If we get the enemies we deserve, then what is this?

Carl Graham is smart. Will he write a book?

You know that old saying that you get the enemies you deserve?   Progressive organizations in Montana appear to have enemies that a dried up potato deserves. It almost makes you feel bad for the other side.
A jumble of words from a man who has nothing to lose, and not much to say arrived in inboxes across Montana recently, when Carl Graham, the President of the Montana Policy  Institute, a right-wing shadow group, sent out his latest email. Under the subject “What’s News From The Montana Policy Institute?”  here’s how it starts:
Let me tell you about the Graham dogs.  One is a border collie mix named Jack.  We don’t know what breed he’s mixed with, but we’re pretty sure it’s fat.
You know what’s not news, Montana Policy Institute?  How fat your dog is.  Graham goes on:
For those of you who don’t know, everyone who moves to Bozeman is issued a Subaru and either a lab, a border collie, or a golden upon arrival.
This is beyond tone-deaf.  Mr. Graham identifies himself with an image that most associate with pretentious yuppies, when in fact most Montanans are stuck driving whatever used car they can afford. It’s clear, however, that some insipid polemics are going to be awkwardly forced in somehow when we get to this part:
We love both our dogs and they both give us much to love. But we also recognize that Jack is more concerned with his own happiness than ours, while Tyson pretty much assumes we can’t be happy if he’s not; so he’ll take everything we’ve got for our own good.
And isn’t that a lesson worth learning from our mutts? Some want to be pretty much left alone to be responsible for their own happiness and fulfillment, which is fine so long as they stay off the couch; while others assume they know what’s good for everyone and the unenlightened among us should just shut up and do what they say.
This is a deep, complex analogy to be sure.  Mr. Graham, what is, in your expert opinion, the deeper meaning behind dogs’ butt sniffing and eating their own vomit?  I can understand if you don’t want to say because, perhaps, you are saving this intellectual gold mine for an upcoming book.
The subject of the Montana Policy Institute’s emails should really read, “Please, PLEASE don’t send us money, because worse than wasting it on hookers and blow, we’ll simply work our hardest to prove that we have nothing really to add to the public discourse.”
Montana Policy Institute President Carl Graham’s entire email is pasted below the fold. UPDATE: As a dog owner, Wulfgar has a different bone to pick with Mr. Graham.  Get his take here.